Assessing responsibility in a car crash where all parties are humans can be difficult, but determining who—or what—is at fault when a self-driving vehicle is involved presents a new complication for the legal system.
But clarity is coming—a federal trial began in Miami last Monday over whether Tesla should be blamed for the 2019 death of 22-year-old Naibel Benavides after she was struck and killed by a Model S on Autopilot with a human driver present.
In this case: George Brian McGee, 48, was behind the wheel, dropped his phone, and reached down to grab it with his foot on the gas. The vehicle blew through a stop sign, striking and killing Benavides and severely injuring her boyfriend, Dillon Angulo, while they were parked legally.
The arguments in Tesla’s first federal jury trial—the company had previously settled at least four suits over fatal crashes—are pitting human vs. machine.